Commissar Graves
SWORD: what Commissar Graves kills
Damage for its points
per 100 pts spent
Its 125 pts kill ~90 pts in one activation.Typical melee unit: 55 per 100
Best against hordes, weakest against light vehicles and monsters
Into each enemy type
Units near it by SWORD
In Astra Militarum
Across the game· melee units
SHIELD: how hard Commissar Graves is to kill for its points
Toughness for its points
per 100 pts spent
Its 125 pts take ~486 pts of enemy units to kill.Typical melee unit: 307 per 100
Units near it by SHIELD
In Astra Militarum
Across the game· melee units
What reviewers say
5 reviewers- Fast, tough distraction 2 of 5
- Good value at launch 1 of 5
- No clear role and little damage 3 of 5
- Price went up 1 of 5
Compare
| Unit | Letter | SWORD | SHIELD | Lists |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commissar Graves125 pts | C | Top 21% | Top 20% | 3of 88 |
| Lord Solar Leontus120 pts | A | Bottom 17% | Bottom 9% | 39of 88 |
| Commissar Yarrick110 pts | B | Bottom 17% | Bottom 4% | 15of 88 |
How we got these numbers
What we ran
Commissar Graves, 125 pts, with its datasheet's weapons, in Grizzled Company. On its own: no leader, no stratagems, no other units' auras. Counted as dice: the army rule and the detachment's rule.
SWORD
Enemy points it kills in one activation, per 100 pts of its own, against a mix of targets weighted like top tournament lists.
125 pts → kills ~90 pts → 72 per 100SHIELD
Enemy points it takes to kill it, per 100 pts of its own: the points of the cheapest units from top lists that kill it 80% of the time. It's per point, so a costly unit has to be much tougher to score the same.
~486 pts → 389 per 100Top and bottom %
Where each number ranks among the game's 572 melee units. How we score.
The letter
The average of 6 reviewers' newest Astra Militarum tier lists: Mordian Glory (smash or pass, every datasheet) (22 Oct), Euan 40k (unit tier list after the September update) (7 Oct), Goonhammer / tabletopbattles.com (September dataslate review, Competitive Innovations: 2 full Guard lists and 5 summaries, 3 to 30 Oct) (30 Oct), Auspex Tactics (unit tier list, and the 20 Oct winning-lists video) (5 Sep), Battleborn 40k (dataslate winners and losers, one Guard player) (1 Oct), 1d6chan (community 11th-edition tactics wiki, August points) (30 Oct). A reviewer who would rather not be counted: tell us.
Lists
88 public Astra Militarum tournament lists, September – November 2026, from grimstat-corpus (CC BY 4.0). Also from Listhammer. Organisers and players: ask us and we'll take a list or an event down. Numbers run 2 Nov.